Which Idea is better ?

[imblogger]

HI,
I m just hang in following ideas I would like to know which one is better

My both ideas are base on Clone of DIGG.com

First is one kind of game you have answer the question
what you will do with 1 million dollar ?
and people will vote for your answer and if you able to collect 100000 votes u will win 1000 dollars
there will be also widget for your blog
people can directly vote from your blog


my second idea is to build ranking selling offers
for example if some one is selling on ebay he will post his ebay deal on site and people can vote deal is good or know
people will be able to promote their estores, ebay dels, backlinks,affiliate programs etc

which one do u think is good ?

[meaghannf]

Well, I think they both need some work but I'd be tempted to say the first one. I'm not going to go put something up on ebay and *then* as if I've made a good deal, I'm going to research it first before I sell it for too little, or nobody bids at all. In that sense, I don't think the second one is very functional.

The first one seems to have some potential simply because the "hot or not" type websites seem to be very popular right now. I'm not sure I entirely understand the idea, though. Maybe flesh it out a bit more and I can give more feedback with a better description.

[akula]

i like the game, because the 2nd idea is unworkable
clearly, anyone who would sit, click and rank advertising content must not be ok

[jasaunders]

I personally don't see either of them as good ideas.

[elle_purchase]

I think you are headed down the right track, just fine tune and work out the details. Eventually, you'll see that the concept may not be as "workable" as you thought. Good luck.