The home page doesn’t really explain what your website is or does — you have text at the bottom (’BRINGING DINNER BACK TO THE TABLE’), but the font is so small is looks more like a footer than content. The flash navigation wheel provides fun eye candy, but I’m not sure how practical it is.

If I were you, I would add a textbox, with a large font size, right in the middle of the front page to describe who you are and what you do. Bring attention to it so readers who visit your site know exactly what the website is about.

Is there any reason why you’ve removed the underlines from the links within the content? For example, on http://www.supperthymeusa.com/gift_certificates.jsp under the headline ‘Ready To Redeem Your Gift Certificate or Gift Card?’, you have some brown links, without bolding or underlining, on a brown background. The links don’t stand out at all — you might consider adding more than just an alternative color to make the links pop out to the reader.

This is just a minor detail, but your navigation header on the front page doesn’t change background color on :hover, but it does on the secondary pages.